George Groves The Movie Sound Pioneer

The Story of the Oscar-Winning Soundman from St Helens, England

The Story of the Oscar-Winning Soundman from St Helens, England

Part 7 - The Jazz Singer: George Groves and Al Jolson (1927)

"Everybody held their breath...It took everybody by storm that he just came out with spoken words” – George Groves

PART 7 - THE JAZZ SINGER: GEORGE GROVES AND AL JOLSON (1927)

"Everybody held their breath...It took everybody by storm that he just came out with spoken words” – George Groves
Colonel Nugent H. Slaughter
Colonel Nugent Slaughter
In April 1927 George Groves and other members of the New York-based Vitaphone team were relocated to Warners' Sunset Boulevard studios in Hollywood. Western Electric veteran Colonel Nugent H. Slaughter, who'd been in Army radio during the war, was detailed as chief recording engineer.

In Fitzhugh Green's 1929 history of "talkie pioneering", The Film Finds Its Tongue, the author wrote that: "George Grove (sic), a quiet little Englishman who had been working with Vitaphone so long, handled the mixing". Warner technician A. M. "Doc" Salomon was seconded to work with the Vitaphone newcomers from New York. Fitzhugh Green described him as a "hard-boiled little fighter who didn't know the word quit".

Vitaphone took over Stage Three on the Warner lot, which was of wooden construction and looked like a barn from the outside. However inside it was state-of-the-art, or as Fitzhugh Green wrote, it was "a scientific marvel of its day". The soundproofed studio was specially designed to shoot talking pictures with careful consideration given to its acoustics, lighting and sound. George was no longer recording the sound from six flights of stairs away from the action, as in the Manhattan Opera House. Instead a special room was constructed adjacent to the set, some 15 feet off the ground. It had glass sides which allowed George to monitor and mix while viewing the action.

The Vitaphone Corporation had its own offices and production department on the lot, although Warner staff provided many services, such as set construction. An increasing number of theatres were investing in the new technology, although they weren't all successful. Of the first 90 to 100 installations, 65 theatres had done excellent business but 25 reported no improvement to their box office returns. A further six sent back their Vitaphone equipment and reverted to silent films. Strong content was considered crucial in preventing such churn and encouraging more theatres to take the plunge.
Vitaphone director Bryan Foy and Jazz Singer poster

Left: Bryan Foy who directed many Vitaphone shorts; Right: A poster for the Jazz Singer

Vitaphone director Bryan Foy and Jazz Singer poster

Bryan Foy who directed many Vitaphone shorts and a Jazz Singer poster

So Vitaphone was asked to score all of Warner Brothers 1927 pictures, although its main task was to make and sell four short subjects a week. They'd learnt from past experience that eight minutes was the optimum duration for a short film and that vaudeville and concert performers went down best with audiences. 29-years-old Bryan Foy, who came from a vaudeville family, was hired to book the acts and direct the shorts. George Groves, a talented amateur musician himself, became used to working with top talent, later saying: "All the great concert and opera stars of the day, I had the privilege of recording."
Elevated stage mixer booth and equipment box at Warners in 1927

Elevated stage mixer booth and equipment box at Warners in 1927 – note improved tubular microphone CTA

Elevated stage mixer booth and equipment box at Warners in 1927

Elevated stage mixer booth and equipment box at Warners in 1927

By the time George arrived in Hollywood, Warners had already begun shooting a picture called The Jazz Singer. It was based on Samson Raphaelson's stage play and director Alan Crosland decided to incorporate some singing sequences. So George was invited to record the soundtrack to what would become a seminal sound film.

He was already acquainted with the picture's star, Al Jolson, having recorded him in 1926 in New York in a ten-minute short subject called A Plantation Act. In this Jolie sang When the Red Red Robin Comes Bob-Bob Bobbin' Along, plus two other songs in blackface make-up. In The Jazz Singer, Jolson – who was third choice for the role of Jakie Rabinowitz – was given six songs to perform, including Toot Toot Tootsie Goodbye, My Mammy and Dirty Hands, Dirty Face.
Jazz Singer scenes

Scenes from the Jazz Singer including when Jolson ad-libbed to his mother who was played by Eugenie Besserer;

Jazz Singer scenes

Scenes from the Jazz Singer including when Jolson ad-libbed

Musical accompaniment was planned for other 'silent' sections of the picture but spoken dialogue was neither scripted nor rehearsed. So the production crew were quite taken aback when Jolson began to ad-lib, as George Groves explained:
 It was all planned that he should sing. In one sequence he came into the set to sit down and play for his mother and purely ad-lib he said "Mother you ain't heard nothing yet". When they saw this stuff [they said] "My gosh he talked". It seemed to be a tremendous surprise...It was done completely ad-lib without rehearsal. Everybody held their breath, then he sang. It took everybody by storm that he just came out with spoken words.  
The Jazz Singer
George also commented on the microphone placement in one scene in the film:
 In one song where he sings to his mother he's in blackface, in a black suit on bended knee on the stage near the end of a show. You'd never know it but there's a microphone on the stand right in front of him and that was all draped in black. And against the black suit you don't see it, when he's down on his knees. When he stood up he went to another microphone overhead.  
George Groves and Al Jolson and a crowd in New York queue to see The Jazz Singer

Left: George Groves and Al Jolson; Right: A crowd in New York queue to see The Jazz Singer

George Groves and Al Jolson and a crowd in New York queue to see The Jazz Singer

Left: Groves and Jolson; Right: A crowd queues to see The Jazz Singer

The film was premiered on October 6th 1927 and was a huge success. It was tagged on promotional posters as "Warners Supreme Triumph" and film historians have labelled it a cinematic landmark. In financial terms alone it was a massive success. Produced by Warners and the Vitaphone Corporation for $422,000, it grossed $2,500,000 at the box office. It demonstrated to the reticent film executives in Hollywood that audiences could, after all, appreciate talking movies. However, not everyone was impressed with the sound innovation. Writer Aldous Huxley commented on his own experience of hearing Al Jolson's performance of My Mammy:
 My flesh crept as the loudspeaker poured out those sodden words, that greasy sagging melody. I felt ashamed of myself for listening to such things, for even being a member of the species to which such things are addressed.  
Warners' Head of Production, Darryl F. Zanuck, was presented with a special Oscar at the very first Academy Awards which took place in 1929 for: "Producing The Jazz Singer, the pioneer outstanding talking picture, which has revolutionized the industry”. With George Groves responsible for the all-important sound within the film, this was also a tribute to the young engineer from St Helens who had followed his Tiller girl fiancé to America not knowing that he would end up at the birth of talking pictures.

George made such an impression on Jolson that he dubbed him "The Quiet Little Englishman" and insisted on him recording all his future pictures. Groves in his oral history – that he recorded for the American Film Institute – remembered how "the world's greatest entertainer" had made a big impression on him too:
 Jolie I thought was a wonderful, wonderful man. ...We were very good friends and I had to do all of his shows. …He was a greater entertainer off the stage than on, in my observations. ...Any time he was off stage and relating some story or anecdote to a group of people, they would stand around absolutely spell-bound.  
Jazz Singer poster
Colonel Nugent H. Slaughter
Nugent H. Slaughter
In April 1927 George Groves and other members of the New York-based Vitaphone team were relocated to Warners' Sunset Boulevard studios in Hollywood.

Western Electric veteran Colonel Nugent H. Slaughter, who'd been in Army radio during the war, was detailed as chief recording engineer.

In Fitzhugh Green's 1929 history of "talkie pioneering", The Film Finds Its Tongue, the author wrote:
 George Grove (sic), a quiet little Englishman who had been working with Vitaphone so long, handled the mixing. 
Warner technician A. M. "Doc" Salomon was seconded to work with the Vitaphone newcomers from New York.

Fitzhugh Green described him as a "hard-boiled little fighter who didn't know the word quit".

Vitaphone took over Stage Three on the Warner lot, which was of wooden construction and looked like a barn from the outside.

However inside it was state-of-the-art, or as Fitzhugh Green wrote, it was "a scientific marvel of its day".

The soundproofed studio was specially designed to shoot talking pictures with careful consideration given to its acoustics, lighting and sound.

George was no longer recording the sound from six flights of stairs away from the action, as in the Manhattan Opera House.

Instead a special room was constructed adjacent to the set, some 15 feet off the ground.

It had glass sides which allowed George to monitor and mix while viewing the action.

The Vitaphone Corporation had its own offices and production department on the lot, although Warner staff provided many services, such as set construction.

An increasing number of theatres were investing in the new technology, although they weren't all successful.

Of the first 90 to 100 installations, 65 theatres had done excellent business but 25 reported no improvement to their box office returns.

A further six sent back their Vitaphone equipment and reverted to silent films.

Strong content was considered crucial in preventing such churn and encouraging more theatres to take the plunge.

So Vitaphone was asked to score all of Warner Brothers 1927 pictures, although its main task was to make and sell four short subjects a week.

They'd learnt from past experience that eight minutes was the optimum duration for a short film and that vaudeville and concert performers went down best with audiences.
Vitaphone director Bryan Foy

Vitaphone director Bryan Foy

29-years-old Bryan Foy, who came from a vaudeville family, was hired to book the acts and direct the shorts.

George Groves, a talented amateur musician himself, became used to working with top talent, later saying:
 All the great concert and opera stars of the day, I had the privilege of recording. 
Elevated stage mixer booth and equipment box at Warners in 1927

Stage mixer booth at Warners in 1927

By the time George arrived in Hollywood, Warners had already begun shooting a picture called The Jazz Singer.

It was based on Samson Raphaelson's stage play and director Alan Crosland decided to incorporate some singing sequences.

So George was invited to record the soundtrack to what would become a seminal sound film.

Al Jolson and Eugenie Besserer

Groves was already acquainted with the picture's star, Al Jolson, having recorded him in 1926 in New York in a ten-minute short subject called A Plantation Act.

In this Jolie sang When the Red Red Robin Comes Bob-Bob Bobbin' Along, plus two other songs in blackface make-up.

In The Jazz Singer, Jolson – who was third choice for the role of Jakie Rabinowitz – was given six songs to perform, including Toot Toot Tootsie Goodbye, My Mammy and Dirty Hands, Dirty Face.
Jazz Singer scene

Scene from The Jazz Singer

Musical accompaniment was planned for other 'silent' sections of the picture but spoken dialogue was neither scripted nor rehearsed.

So the production crew were quite taken aback when Jolson began to ad-lib, as George Groves explained:
 It was all planned that he should sing. In one sequence he came into the set to sit down and play for his mother and purely ad-lib he said "Mother you ain't heard nothing yet". When they saw this stuff [they said] "My gosh he talked". It seemed to be a tremendous surprise...It was done completely ad-lib without rehearsal. Everybody held their breath, then he sang. It took everybody by storm that he just came out with spoken words.  
Jazz Singer title
George also commented on the microphone placement in one scene in the film:
 In one song where he sings to his mother he's in blackface, in a black suit on bended knee on the stage near the end of a show. You'd never know it but there's a microphone on the stand in front of him and that was all draped in black. And against the black suit you don't see it, when he's down on his knees. When he stood up he went to another microphone overhead.  
 The film was premiered on October 6th 1927 and was a huge success.

It was tagged on promotional posters as "Warners Supreme Triumph" and film historians have labelled it a cinematic landmark.

In financial terms alone it was a massive success. Produced by Warners and the Vitaphone Corporation for $422,000, it grossed $2,500,000 at the box office.

It demonstrated to the reticent film executives in Hollywood that audiences could, after all, appreciate talking movies.

However, not everyone was impressed with the sound innovation.

Writer Aldous Huxley commented on his own experience of hearing Al Jolson's performance of My Mammy:
 My flesh crept as the loudspeaker poured out those sodden words, that greasy sagging melody. I felt ashamed of myself for listening to such things, for even being a member of the species to which such things are addressed.  
Warners' Head of Production, Darryl F. Zanuck, was presented with a special Oscar at the very first Academy Awards which took place in 1929 for:

"Producing The Jazz Singer, the pioneer outstanding talking picture, which has revolutionized the industry”.
George Groves and Al Jolson

George Groves and Al Jolson

With George Groves responsible for the all-important sound within the film, this was also a tribute to the young engineer from St Helens who had followed his Tiller girl fiancé to America not knowing that he would end up at the birth of talking pictures.

George made such an impression on Jolson that he dubbed him "The Quiet Little Englishman" and insisted on him recording all his future pictures.

Groves in his oral history – that he recorded for the American Film Institute – remembered how "the world's greatest entertainer" had made a big impression on him too:
 Jolie I thought was a wonderful, wonderful man. ...We were very good friends and I had to do all of his shows. …He was a greater entertainer off the stage than on, in my observations. ...Any time he was off stage and relating some story or anecdote to a group of people, they would stand around absolutely spell-bound.